Community discussions indicate Franklin X-40 balls are susceptible to cracking when used in colder outdoor conditions, specifically noted around 30-40°F (4-4.5°C). This brittleness is a concern for players during fall and winter matches. While some players attempt mitigation by keeping balls in pockets to retain warmth, the polymer material can still become brittle. This contrasts with their performance in warmer weather, leading many players to switch to alternative balls like Selkirk Pro S1 or Diadem tournament balls during winter months for better resilience against temperature-induced failure.

r/pickleball community discussions

In very hot conditions, approximately 95-100°F (35-38°C), users report that the X-40 balls become noticeably soft and 'squishy' due to heat expansion affecting the polymer. This significantly alters their bounce characteristics and flight trajectory, making it harder to generate pace and encouraging a softer, dink-focused game. While they do not crack in the heat, their altered elasticity means some players prefer balls like Dura for superior consistency in extreme temperatures, as the X-40's responsiveness diminishes.

r/pickleball community discussions

User feedback highlights occasional quality control concerns, including reports of balls with off-center or poorly formed seams, which can negatively affect flight stability and predictability. There are also discussions about susceptibility to cracking in cold weather around 4°C and a tendency to soften in extreme heat around 35°C. While many users report consistent performance over extended periods, these isolated incidents involving material integrity and manufacturing precision lead to mixed sentiments regarding long-term durability and batch-to-batch consistency.

r/pickleball community discussions

The Franklin X-40 is frequently described by players as a consistent ball with a predictable speed and bounce, serving as a baseline standard for general play. Competitor balls, such as Selkirk, Diadem, and Vulcan, are often characterized as harder, leading to faster play and higher bounces that can facilitate more aggressive strategies. While the X-40 offers reliable consistency and is valued for its balanced flight pattern, players seeking a more aggressive, faster-paced game might prefer the characteristics of these other brands, though some note Selkirk balls can become 'egg-shaped' over time.

r/pickleball community discussions